A Future Worth Belonging To

Why work, opportunity and connection matter to the wellbeing of our young people

As a mum of a 17- and 21-year-old the news this week has been of particular interest to me.  Two big stories on Andy Burnham and closer ties to Europe and the Milburn report into young people not in education, employment or training seem to be talking about two different things, apparently unrelated, and yet there are threads that bind the two inextricably together.

Both raise the same fundamental question: are we giving young people the opportunities, relationships and sense of purpose that they need to flourish.

For young people, a sense of belonging has several themes.  They need to feel valued and that they have something to contribute to society in a wider sense. They need to be part of relationships, communities and have shared experiences with not only their peers but a wider demographic to truly understand what it means to be in community. They need to have a sense of identity, purpose and direction that is founded in something solid, not just in a feeling or emotion, and they need to believe that there is a future in which they have a meaningful place, that their contribution counts for something and matters.

Logos Scotland Seen and Known report found that young people are lonelier than other generations, that they feel disconnected from community and have a lower sense of belonging than other age groups.

Belonging isn’t just about where we live, it is about the connectedness of how we feel and experience in our place and that we have opportunities in the world around us to participate and contribute.

The Milburn review explores the relationship between meaningful work and wellbeing.  It recognises that mental health is important when it comes to work and they are inextricably linked together. You cannot work with poor mental health, and work helps us have good mental health, they have a symbiotic relationship that is integral to our wellbeing.

Work creates relationships and social connection, it gives us a sense of purpose in our communities and provides structure, confidence and purpose. It allows us to contribute to something that is bigger than ourselves and achieve more collectively than we could do ourselves.

While our worth is not determined by our employment it certainly has a significant place within it. Tackling NEETS is not just an economic issue, it will benefit society as a whole, a point I made on STV’s Scotland Tonight on Monday night.

Also this week Andy Burnham made a speech that promised closer links to the European Union.  Attending the summit to meet with other European leaders, he promised closer ties, cooperation, movement of people and goods.  In particular a return to the Erasmus scheme allowing our young people to travel in Europe for work and cultural exchanges. 

There, again, was a big focus on the benefits to young people in experiencing different cultures and broadening of horizons.  Living, learning and working abroad to develop confidence and independence.  Having new experiences, discovering new abilities, interests and aspirations were all central to the Prime Ministers message.

Belonging to a community does not mean staying in one place, we can explore and find new horizons that we never knew existed, while remaining rooted in our own communities and families. And from a Logos perspective, in God and our faith.

As parents, we bring our kids up to fly. We nurture and protect them while pushing them to explore.  I remember my eldest son at around 6 years old asking if he could cycle down a rather steep flight of stairs, “I don’t know”, I answered, “can you?” while holding my hand over my eyes and having outstretched arms to catch him if he fell.  That balance, as a parent, of encouraging them to push the boundaries while providing the safety net to catch them. (He successfully cycled down the stairs.)

Young people need roots; supportive relationships, stable communities, opportunities to contribute and a sense of being valued.

But they also need wings; freedom to explore, take risks, develop independence and imagine possibilities beyond their (and our) immediate circumstances.

Neither is sufficient on its own. Without roots opportunities can become overwhelming; without relationships opportunities can leave people feeling disconnected; true wellbeing requires both security and freedom to grow.

Policies that impact young people need to be sufficiently ambitious to allow them to discover who they can become but also firmly rooted in something solid to remember where they came from and the values that nurtured them.

The Milburn Review understandably considers employment, welfare and economic participation. The EU discussions consider mobility, opportunity and international cooperation.  But neither employment statistics nor opportunities to travel can tell us everything about whether young people are flourishing.

Instead we also have to measure and understand the importance of mental and emotional wellbeing, meaningful relationships, purpose and contribution, hope and aspiration, community, family and health. At Logos Scotland we also believe that there is a faith element to wellbeing, a holistic approach that not only looks at the body and mind but also the soul.  Where are our beliefs rooted and on what foundation are they built? Where does our help and hope come from, the Psalms are quite clear.

We cannot measure the success of our young people simply through the miles they travel or the economic productivity that they have.  It surely has to be more than that and include their deeper wellbeing and sense of belonging.

Both policy announcements this week have the capacity to make things better for our future generations.  One seeks to help them find their place in society and the other to widen the opportunities available to them.  Both have the potential to make important contributions to the wellbeing of future generations but the real measure of success will not be how many young people travel abroad or how many find a job.

Our ambition as a society, and as politicians, must match the ambition we have for our young people. We should want them to explore the world, take risks, find meaningful work and discover all that life has to offer. But we should want more for them than simply a job or a passport full of stamps. We should want them to know who they are, where they belong and that their contribution to the world matters. We need to give them the confidence to spread their wings, but also the roots that will sustain them when life becomes difficult. Because ultimately, the measure of a flourishing generation is not simply how far they go or how much they achieve, but whether they have the purpose, hope and belonging to build a life worth living.